I guess now you have information on how this guy plays. Expensive information though. Yuck.
Did you have any notes on this guy? I hope you do NOW, at any rate.
This is what I would think, and why I would fold, if it happened down on one of my little tables. A lot of people at GC play very passively. They prefer to call bets, both when they have a monster and when they have very little. The only way you can know which is which is by betting small. Then if they have a monster they get frustrated and raise you big. You can then fold.
Is the $50 bet into a $115 pot really a value bet? It looks too big to me. I would think that even with KQ he's not going to be willing to call more than $30 or so, about 1/4 of the pot. Maybe with AQ, I suppose. Maybe my value bets have always been too small?
I agree that he made a bad play on the river and that he won't get called there most of the time. But that's the point of being a good player, isn't it? Make the good plays yourself, and don't pay off the bad ones? I'm a little disappointed you called him.
Or maybe he makes money playing like this
because it mystifies people so they have to call just to see wtf he is doing?